Review published on November 14, 2017.
After a shocking, violent prologue, this book settles into a family drama reminiscent of the best of Anne Enright. Alison is preparing for her second marriage in Ballygrass, Northern Ireland. Her mother is fearful of a return of a serious illness, her father gets confused, her sister is accepting the break-up of yet another relationship and her brother has secrets of his own. The author pitches these family dynamics perfectly, the characters are well-rounded with modern, on-point references and the first part of the novel is an unpredictable joy. In the second part, sister Liz travels to New Ulster Island off Papua New Guinea to film a BBC documentary about a new religion. The author opened up my eyes to Cargo Cults, which is something I knew nothing about yet in moving to this second narrative strand some of the vivacity and the power of the novel is diluted. This is always a risk (I felt exactly the same recently about Zadie Smith’s Swing Time) as there is a danger that the reader will favour one strand more than the other and although I enjoyed reading about Liz’s chilling experience of disastrous western intervention, I was itching to get back to Ireland where there were equally difficult situations regarding fanaticism to resolve.
The sections do link together and I can see what the author is trying to convey. I think reading groups not afraid to tackle conflicts over religions both old and new will find much to consider. It’s a very good third novel from this prize-winning Irish author and certainly for the first half I thought it was going to be an exceptional one. I will certainly seek out his earlier works.
Phil Ramage 4/4
Modern Gods by Nick Laird
Fourth Estate 9780008257323 hbk Jun 2017
Reading Group Guide: The Dreams of Bethany Mellmoth by William Boyd
Histories by Sam Guglani
You may also like
From the outset you know that almost everyone’s going to be OK. The question is ......
“Eileen”, American author Moshfegh’s second novel is a first person narrative, largely an escape plan ......