Foul Trade by B.K. Duncan

Review published on December 22, 2017.

What appealed to me about Foul Trade as soon as I read the blurb was the fact that May Keaps, the main character, is the Poplar Coroner’s Officer. Poplar is an interesting place to read about, being known for being quite run down and impoverished. And then there’s the fact of May’s job which has so much potential for intriguing storylines, especially in 1920 when it’s not considered to be a job for a female and she’s only really there because of the effect of the Great War.

I last met up with May in The Last Post, a novella set in 1918. I liked her a lot then and this full-length novel didn’t change my mind about her. May is feisty and clever and very likeable. She’s one of those people who seems to get herself into all sorts of situations, sometimes dangerous ones but is incredibly brave about it. I’m not sure whether, in reality, a woman in her position would have done half of the things she does in Foul Trade, but it certainly made for an interesting read and I’d love to know more about the author’s research as I bet it was fascinating.

I also really liked the Coroners that May ends up working for. Both made me smile at times and I found them to be really interesting and complex characters.

Duncan’s writing style is quite perceptive and a little bit sardonic at times. I marked this passage as it made me smile:

“She’d filled a further hour with pointless and unsatisfactory housework before her sister was back with her pasty-faced friend in her shadow. May hadn’t seen Elaine for a while and burgeoning womanhood wasn’t treating her well; her hair was lank, her chin dotted with white-headed spots, and her arms seemingly welded across her chest to hide her emerging bosoms. May secretly hoped that the dream of becoming an actress wasn’t a shared one or Elaine would be very disappointed. Alice was striking with dark hair and blue-grey eyes but she also made the air in a room shiver with energy whenever she entered. Elaine sort of plopped into a vacant space. May suspected it was an awareness of this contrast that made Alice like to go around with her.”

The story covers drug addiction, Chinese turf wars and a gaiety show that May’s sister, Alice, is linked with. There’s a lot going on and I did think the book was maybe a little tiny bit on the long side (there’s an awful lot going on!) but ultimately it’s intriguing with a fabulously sharp heroine. I do like Duncan’s way with words and I think we may be seeing more of May Keaps.

Nicola Smith, Short Book and Scribes, 4/4

Foul Trade by B.K. Duncan
Bloodhound Books 9781912175826 pbk Dec 2017


Idaho by Emily Ruskovich


Deep Blue Trouble by Steph Broadribb

You may also like