The Stranger by Kate Riordan

Review published on April 17, 2018.

The tagline “In a house full of strangers, who can you trust?” is perfect for this book. Three land girls are thrown together at Penhallow Hall in Cornwall, thrust into a house with secrets and sadness at the heart of it. Rose, Diana and Jane are complete opposites in every way and have to learn to live with each other.

I found The Stranger to be a fascinating and enthralling read, pretty much unputdownable. Rose was my favourite character and somehow her story seemed to me to be the most prominent one, even though Diana is by far the more memorable character. Rose is pleasant and kind, but unfulfilled. She remembers a holiday half a lifetime ago which has shaped the whole of her life since. Diana is much younger than Rose and very damaged, the sort of woman who causes trouble wherever she goes, stirring up things that are best left alone, but somehow always getting away with it. And Jane, well there’s more to Jane’s presence at Penhallow than meets the eye, but I shall leave it for you to find out her story for yourself.

The whole setting in this book is crucial to the storyline. The brooding house, the pirate’s coves, the small village setting, the boathouse. All of these add a gothic feel to the story and it’s hard to imagine the author setting it anywhere else but Cornwall.

It’s not a book with a clear beginning to end story, more a slice of life, a snapshot of a time in 1940 when three Land Girls shook up their own lives and those of the inhabitants of Penhallow Hall. The descriptions are simply beautiful, there’s a sense of foreboding throughout and I could feel thunderclouds gathering, building up to the end.

The author uses a clever device to tell us what Diana is up to by the use of a diary. This meant that Diana’s inner thoughts were revealed only to the reader, not to the other characters. I witnessed Diana wreaking havoc and taking great delight in it with a sense of apprehension all the way through the story and it certainly posted a moral dilemma to me: could I forgive Diana because I knew what she had gone through in her past, or was her nasty streak just part of her personality? I’m still a little undecided.

The Stranger is atmospheric, intense and full of drama. It has quite a melancholic feel at times, an underlying sense of sadness, but it’s wonderfully observed and had me totally hooked. The writing is just lovely and I found it to be a fantastic read.

Nicola Smith, Short Book and Scribes, 5/4

The Stranger by Kate Riordan
Michael Joseph 9780718188061 hbk Mar 2018


Author meets Reviewer: Libby Page meets Jade Craddock


In the Blink of an Eye by Ali Bacon

You may also like